If you ask locals where in Thomaston, CT you can savor the best variety of food, most will point you straight to Hickory Hill. Nestled on the eastern side of town, this neighborhood combines cozy, family-run eateries with inventive new kitchens, making it a true destination for foodies. From bakeries on Hickory Hill Road to cafes tucked along the Main Street corridor, here are the standouts that make eating in Hickory Hill a joy any day of the week.
Classic Comfort at Junction 254
*Cuisine:* American diner
*Price Range:* $
*Where:* Intersection of Hickory Hill Road & East Main Street
Nothing says neighborhood staple like Junction 254. This diner, perched right at a bustling intersection, is a local favorite for breakfast and lunch. Here, the pancakes are fluffy, the corned beef hash is made in-house, and regulars swear by the chicken pot pie. The service is friendly and the portions are generous—expect your coffee mug to be refilled before you even notice it's empty.
*Must-try:* Biscuits and gravy, weekend eggs Benedict, and their famous homemade pies.
A Taste of Italy: Bella Trattoria
*Cuisine:* Italian
*Price Range:* $$
*Where:* Hickory Hill Road near Oakdene Avenue
When you’re in the mood for Italian, Bella Trattoria delivers old-world charm and modern flavors. Their wood-fired pizzas feature locally sourced toppings, and their pasta is made fresh daily. Couples love the cozy booths, while families reserve the big round tables for Sunday dinner. Their tiramisu is light and decadent, and the wine list features both Italian imports and favorites from Connecticut vineyards.
*Must-try:* Eggplant parmigiana, wild mushroom risotto, and margherita pizza with house-made mozzarella.
Caffeine Fix & More: Maple Run Café
*Cuisine:* Café/Bakery
*Price Range:* $
*Where:* Maple Avenue, just off Hickory Hill Road
Maple Run Café is Hickory Hill's answer to artisan coffee and fresh pastries. Locals crowd in every morning for the espresso drinks (beans roasted nearby in Litchfield County) and the famous almond croissants. The lunch menu is equally impressive—think house-made quiches, vegan wraps, and inventive salad bowls. On Saturdays, Maple Run hosts a “Breakfast Breads Festival” that always sells out early.
*Must-try:* Maple walnut scones, iced vanilla oat latte, and the rotating lunch special.
The Hidden Gem: Pat’s Polish Food Truck
*Cuisine:* Polish, Eastern European street food
*Price Range:* $
*Where:* Usually parked near the Hickory Hill Playground (check social media for weekly schedule)
Locals “in the know” will tell you to hunt down Pat’s Polish Food Truck for some of the best comfort food in town. Pat serves house-made pierogi, kielbasa on fresh rolls, and tangy cucumber salad, all from a cheery red truck. The stuffed cabbage rolls are a fan favorite. Everything is made from scratch and the portions are more than generous. Come early—the best desserts (like poppyseed cake) often sell out.
*Must-try:* Potato-cheese pierogi, beef goulash, and Polish-style apple fritters.
Sweet Tooth Heaven: Nutmeg Lane Bakery
*Cuisine:* Bakery
*Price Range:* $
*Where:* Nutmeg Lane, just east of Hickory Hill Road
Nutmeg Lane Bakery has been a Hickory Hill institution since 1962. Still run by the third generation of the founding family, this spot is known for its old-school baked goods and welcoming, small-town vibe. Go for breakfast Danish and glazed donuts, but don’t skip the fresh bread (especially the honey-wheat loaf). In autumn, their pumpkin muffins are legendary.
*Must-try:* Coffee cake slices, epic apple turnovers, and custom birthday cakes with rolled fondant.
Family Feasts at The Brass Lantern
*Cuisine:* New England American, Seafood
*Price Range:* $$-$$$
*Where:* Located on East Main Street, right at the crest of Hickory Hill
For hearty New England fare with a subtle modern twist, The Brass Lantern is the neighborhood’s go-to. The chef sources local veggies and fish whenever possible, crafting everything from classic clam chowder to creative daily specials. Sunday suppers here are a tradition—roast chicken, baked cod, and platters of mashed potatoes fly out of the kitchen. The atmosphere strikes a balance between fancy and relaxed, making it perfect for a date night or a family get-together.
*Must-try:* Lobster mac and cheese, beer-battered haddock, and house-made maple bread pudding.
Quick Bites: Hickory Hill Plaza Eats
There’s more to Hickory Hill than sit-down spots—sometimes you just want something quick, fresh, and delicious. Swing by the Hickory Hill Plaza (on Hickory Hill Road just by the shopping center) for a cluster of quick eats:
- *Sam’s Shawarma Stand*: Middle Eastern wraps and platters; the falafel is crisp and the garlic sauce legendary.
- *East Valley Sushi*: Perfect for takeout, with spicy tuna rolls and bento boxes.
- *Gianni’s Gelato Cart*: Parked out front on summer afternoons, with rotating flavors and plenty of dairy-free options.
Food Traditions & Neighborhood Flavor
What truly sets Hickory Hill apart is its tradition of food-centered community events. Every spring, the neighborhood hosts the Hickory Hill Food Fest right at the intersection of Hickory Hill Road and East Main, with tastings from local vendors and live cooking demos. The annual autumn bake sale outside Nutmeg Lane Bakery brings out secret family recipes you won’t find on any menu.
Beyond the events, this is a neighborhood where chefs and bakers know their customers by name. Whether you’re grabbing a croissant, a pizza, or a pierogi, expect to be greeted like an old friend—and don’t hesitate to ask for their favorite off-menu item!
Final Bites: Where to Start
With so much to choose from, here’s how I’d eat through a perfect food day in Hickory Hill:
- Morning: I’d start at Maple Run Café for a pastry and a specialty coffee, then stroll up to Nutmeg Lane Bakery for some take-home sweets.
- Lunch: Junction 254 for hearty diner classics or Pat’s Polish Food Truck for something unique.
- Afternoon Snack: Gianni’s Gelato Cart for a cool treat or Sam’s Shawarma Stand for a quick bite.
- Dinner: A lingering meal at Bella Trattoria or The Brass Lantern, depending on your craving and company.
Whatever your taste and whatever your budget, Hickory Hill’s dining scene welcomes every palate and promises you’ll leave both full and happy. Bon appétit, Thomaston!